Each alternative school has its own distinct profile, however, most of them embrace some of the following characteristics—they provide an option for students, parents, and teachers; they are committed to be more responsive to the educational needs within the community than conventional school; they have more comprehensive goals, are more flexible and responsive to feedback and change, and are smaller than conventional schools (Conley, 2002). Alternative schools also tend to be more attuned to the child’s needs instead of following “narrow age-classified groups” (Kraftl, 2013), they value learning as “imminent to life itself” (Falk et al, 2009) and regard meaningful and personalized relationships as essential in education (Rudge, 2010, 2016). The most common and widely spread alternative approaches to schooling are Steiner schools, Montessori schools, democratic/free schools, Reggio Emilia schools, and forest schools. Other approaches to education include homeschooling, unschooling, and online learning. The IB programs also offer a differentiated curriculum that is child centered, especially for younger grades. Most of these alternative approaches to education are privately funded and independent from government control, however, in North America, Europe, and Australasia, some of these alternative models of education have been incorporated into the public system. Below is a brief summary of some of the most popular alternative education systems adopted by schools around the world. 

Montessori Education:  Developed by Maria Montessori, this approach emphasizes individualized learning, hands-on activities, and self-directed exploration. Montessori classrooms are designed to promote independence, with a focus on individual progress and developmental milestones. Students are encouraged to learn at their own pace in a supportive learning environment. To learn more, visit https://amshq.org/About-Montessori

Waldorf Education: Inspired by Rudolf Steiner, Waldorf schools focus on the holistic development of the child (body, mind, and spirit) through a rich and balanced curriculum that includes academics, art, music, movement, and hands-on learning. Its educational approach is aligned with the child’s developmental stages, as defined by Steiner. Waldorf education places strong emphasis on artistic expression, creativity, imagination, and experiential learning. For further information, visit https://www.waldorfeducation.org/

Reggio Emilia Approach: Developed by Loris Malaguzzi and parents, its approach is known for its child-centered, experiential, and project-based approach to learning. Children are  seen as competent, capable, and active constructors of their own knowledge. They are respected as unique individuals with rights, opinions, and ideas. The role of the educator is to facilitate and support their learning journey. This approach is widely implemented in early childhood settings. For further information, visit https://www.reggiochildren.it/en/reggio-emilia-approach/ 

Forest Schools: A concept originated in Scandinavia, Forest schools place a strong emphasis on learning in natural outdoor environments, typically forests and woodlands. The learning environment is often child-led, allowing them to engage in self-directed play and discovery. Forest schools often operate as part-time programs, complementing regular classroom-based education. For further information, visit https://forestschoolassociation.org/what-is-forest-school/ 

Free/Democratic Schools: Also known as Sudbury schools, these schools operate on the principle of self-governance and individual freedom. They prioritize the rights and autonomy of students, allowing them to have a significant say in the decision-making process of their education and the daily life of the school. Students are encouraged to engage in self-directed learning, pursue their interests, and learn through real life experiences, without following a set curriculum. For further information, visit https://sudburyvalley.org/essays/what-it-takes-create-democratic-school 

International Baccalaureate (IB) Programs: The IB program is an internationally recognized program offered in many schools around the world, both private and public. IB programs focus on inquiry-based learning, international mindedness, and the development of lifelong learners. IB integrates four programs, Primary Years Program (PYP), Middle Years Program (MYP), Diploma Program (DP), and Career-Related Program (CP).  Schools may offer any of these programs or all of them. For further information, visit https://www.ibo.org/programmes/ 

Integrated Programs: Many schools blend principles, theories and pedagogies of several systems of education. The IB programs are an example of it.

It's important to note that these alternative approaches may not be suitable for every student or family. Each approach has its own advantages and challenges. It is essential to consider the unique needs of the child as well as the parents’ educational goals and values  when exploring alternative education options. Also, schools may claim to offer a specific approach but may not implement it accordingly. Some education systems, like Waldorf and IB programs, have a rigorous process of evaluation to authorize a school to offer their curriculum, whereas others do not have such a requirement. In any case, it is important to always verify if the school is a recognized member of the education organization (e.g. American Montessori Society, Association of Waldorf Schools in North America). 

References:

Conley, B.E. (2002). Alternative schools: A reference handbook. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO.

Falk, J. H., Heimlich, J. E., & Foutz, S. (2009). Free-choice learning and the environment. Lanham: AltaMira.

Kraftl, P. (2013). Geographies of alternative education: Diverse learning spaces for children and young people. Bristol: Policy Press.

Riddle, S. & Cleaver, D. (2017). Working within and against the grain of policy in an alternative school. Discourse Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 38(4), 498-510.

Rudge, L. (2010). Holistic education: An analysis of its pedagogical application. Saarbrücken, Germany: Lambert Academic Publishing.

Rudge, L. (2016). Holistic pedagogy in public schools: A case study of three alternative schools. Other Education: The Journal of Educational Alternatives, 5(2), 169-195.

Woods, P.A. & Woods, G.J. (Eds.). (2009). Alternative education for the 21st century: Philosophies, approaches, visions. New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan.

Permalink

]]>Alternative Approaches to Education: Exploring Options Beyond Traditional SchoolsLucila RudgeWed, 05 Jul 2023 20:43:53 +0000https://lucilarudgecoachingconsulting.com/blog/blog-post-title-one-4d2zt-kh8c6630e8139b7842f31fd0842a1:64a496fa80ab2d7d7c48c194:64a5d46657efea02ee13c0ddIt is not always easy and straightforward to choose the right school for our children. Many factors can influence our choices. We might pick a school because it is in our neighborhood, or we pick a school that we attended, or maybe family and friends recommended, or we like a specific educational approach. But what if the school you chose is not working for your children? What if the school is not meeting your expectations? What would you do? You might try to work with the school to have them cater to the needs of your child; you might try to adjust your expectations, or you might look for alternatives, another school, another method, or maybe consider homeschool. 

If you decide to look for a school for your child, either because you are not happy with the current school or you have just begun the search for your first child, you will need to carefully evaluate the options available in your town/city. I have listed below several points for you to consider as you go through the process of choosing a school for your child. 

PRELIMINARY STEPS

• Begin your search by reflecting on your values, principles, and the expectations you have for your child’s education. You might want to draw a list of about 5-10 values and expectations and then rate them in order of importance for you. Reflect on the ones that are most important to you. 

• There are many types of schools out there with different pedagogical approaches. Do you favor any specific educational approach (Montessory, Waldorf, Reggio, Democratic, etc.)? What is in this method that attracts you?

• Consider your child’s needs and strengths. Does your child need a more or less structured environment? Does your child have any special learning needs? Would your child benefit from a school that focuses more on the arts, STEM, outdoor environment, or academics in general?

• Is the location important for you and your child? Consider the advantages or disadvantages of  transportation, playing with friends, joining after school activities, etc.

• Gather as much information as you can about the schools you are considering (curriculum, courses offered, foreign language, extracurricular activities, support for special learning needs, teachers qualification). You can gather this information online before visiting the schools. 

• Learning about the school’s approach to learning can be fuzzy sometimes. Some schools might say they adopt a particular approach but in reality they don’t. Visiting the school is essential to check their approach. Searching for evidence from other parents or sources would also be beneficial. Try to learn from their website what they propose and ask direct questions on how they implement what they claim. That will give you a good idea about their implementation. 

• If academic performance is very important to you, you should try to get the school’s report card. It is easier to obtain that from public schools. If it is a private school, you will have to ask for that information. 

• Does the school offer additional opportunities, such as field trips, extracurricular activities, parent participation, community involvement? Is that important for you?

• Consider the school facilities and resources. How well equipped the school is? Do they have a library, sports facilities, space for the Arts, etc? Do they have special education teachers, consolours, or nurses on duty?

• The application process can be challenging in some schools. Make sure you ask all questions about the process to avoid any unpleasant surprises. If you are interested in a private school, besides asking about the tuition fee, you may also ask if they have a sliding scale for tuition based on family income or if they offer scholarships. Sometimes there are some additional fees and expenses that are not clearly laid out. Be alert on asking about those as well. 

VISITING THE SCHOOL

• Visiting the school is essential. The school website may be wonderful but the real school might be very different from what it was portrayed, or the reverse might also be true. Some schools offer open houses with tours for groups of parents. Those are good ways to learn about the school. They tend to provide a comprehensive overview of what they offer. 

• Scheduling an additional visit to the school  will help see more of the school and observe other aspects of the school that you usually cannot see in an open house tour. Make an appointment with the principal and ask if it is possible to observe a classroom. 

• In your visit to the school, ask the principal as many questions as you can. Come prepared with the questions. Your initial research should give you the basis to draw your questions. 

• Listen closely to teachers and students what they say about the school. 

• Observe the culture of the school. Does it promote a welcoming environment? How is student work displayed? Do students and teachers appear content with the school? Is the staff friendly? How does the school communicate with students, parents, and teachers? How do teachers communicate with parents? How do teachers treat students? 

• Observe how classrooms are set up, how desks are organized, or if there are any desks. Do students work in groups or mostly individually? What is the culture of testing and assessments? 

• Asks the principal and teachers about the philosophy and pedagogical approach of the school. Cross check with what you have learned from their school website. Have a few questions prepared about how they would implement X, Y, and Z. 

• Do students spend time outdoors? How long? What is their policy for recess?

• Observe the school facilities, the books displayed in the library, the sports facilities, the space for the Arts, the common areas, and so on. 

• Observe the demographics of the school and the school’s attitude toward diverse students and diversity in general. 

It is recommended that parents visit a few schools before selecting what is the best choice for their children. You might want to consider applying to more than one school, in case your child is not admitted in their first choice. Best wishes for your search!

Permalink

]]>Choosing the Right School: Factors to Consider